top of page
Search

Tankless vs Tank Water Heaters: What’s Best for Orange County Homes?

Writer: Oliver Owens
Oliver Owens
Oct 30
8 min read

When it comes to tankless versus tank water heaters, you have to consider more than which is the latest technology


Most homeowners don’t start looking into replacing their water heaters until the existing unit

begins to cause them problems.

Tank Water Heaters

Perhaps the hot water is running out too quickly, or water is leaking from the tank, or the unit is making strange noises. It could also be because the water heater is so old, no one even knows how long it has been installed. It is usually around this point that they ask themselves, “Should we keep the same model or go with something else?” Homeowners in Placentia and throughout North Orange County are frequently asking these questions at Kramer’s Plumbing. Tankless water heaters can be a fantastic option, but they are not always the most appropriate solution for every home.


Traditional water heaters continue to be a popular choice among homeowners due to their level of familiarity. Replacing a traditional tank water heater with another traditional tank is often the simplest option if the existing location of the water heater, its venting, lines, gas supply, and shutoffs, are all in good condition. This does not mean it will be a quick and inexpensive project, however. Code requirements, valves, venting, access, and tank sizes can complicate many jobs.



Here’s what you need to know about traditional

water heaters


Traditional, or storage, water heaters heat and store hot water in a tank for later use. Once

the hot water has been used, cold water enters the tank to be heated for the next use.


These water heaters are great because they are familiar to most people. If you already have

a traditional water heater and want to replace it, it is usually simple to install another

traditional unit. If the location, venting, lines, gas supply, and shutoffs are all in good

condition, you can likely have a traditional tank water heater installed in a matter of hours or

days. Replacing a traditional water heater with a tankless option may be appropriate for

some homes, but it is rarely the simplest solution.


Here’s what you need to know about tankless

water heaters


Instead of heating and holding hot water in a tank, tankless water heaters typically provide a

continuous flow of hot water.


Because of this, many people are drawn to these types of systems, believing that they will

save them money and provide a steadier supply of hot water. ENERGY STAR certified gas

tankless water heaters are designed to heat water only when needed and can save money

on energy bills while providing a continuous flow of hot water.


While tankless water heaters typically offer more savings and flexibility, they should not be

chosen simply because they are new technology. They may also require a far more involved

installation process and can be more expensive to purchase and install. Before deciding that

a tankless water heater is best, it is important to understand how these systems work and

what they require.


The appeal of tankless systems


One of the main reasons homeowners are interested in tankless water heaters is the ability

to have an endless supply of hot water. If you choose the right size and type of tankless

system for your home, it should be able to provide a steady flow of hot water for as long as

you need it. This can be a major benefit for families who all take showers one right after

another or for those who find that their existing storage tank is not providing nearly enough

hot water.


Another benefit of tankless systems is that they are mounted on a wall rather than taking up

valuable square footage in a home. This frees up space, which can be a major consideration

for some homeowners.


In addition, tankless systems can save energy. These systems do not constantly heat a tank

of water, so they typically use less energy than traditional water heaters. ENERGY STAR

recommends whole-home gas tankless water heaters for their potential to provide

significant savings.


Why traditional water heaters still have appeal


As mentioned, traditional water heaters typically offer less flexibility than their tankless

counterparts. They do, however, tend to be simpler to install and less expensive to purchase

and install. If your existing traditional water heater has been working well and you are happy

with the amount of hot water it provides, another traditional water heater is likely the best

option. It may also provide a steadier supply of hot water than a tankless system. Tank

storage heaters are ideal in many situations and for many types of homes.


The main downside to traditional storage water heaters is the fact that they can only provide

a limited amount of hot water before the tank needs to replenish. If you are finding that your

home is regularly running out of hot water, you may need to have your water heater replaced

or repaired.



Installation costs can be a deciding factor when

choosing between a tankless and traditional

water heater


Many people who are considering the switch to tankless water heaters are surprised to learn

just how much the job can cost.


Tankless systems typically require a major installation that can cost significantly more than

replacing a traditional water heater with another traditional water heater.


Some of the costs that come with a tankless installation include sizing the system to fit the

needs of your home, gas line modifications, venting, electricity, condensate, mounting,

plumbing, permits, and code upgrades. A traditional water heater replacement can also be

expensive based on the condition of the existing lines, shutoffs, gas supply, and venting.

While price comparisons between traditional and tankless water heaters can be informative,

it is important to remember that costs can vary greatly from one home to the next.


It’s time for some math


It is important to think about how much hot water you need in your home.


A family of two with a single bathroom will have far fewer needs than a family of six with

two bathrooms. Tankless water heaters will require sizing based on temperature and flow

rates, so if you have too many fixtures, the water heater will not be able to provide an

adequate supply of hot water. Traditional water heaters will require an appropriate amount

of storage and recovery, and if you have too many people using the hot water at the same

time, you may find that the tank is never big enough.


The importance of regular maintenance


Both types of water heaters require regular maintenance in order to function at peak

efficiency. Traditional water heaters need to be flushed on a regular basis in order to remove

sediment. The EPA recommends that water heaters be flushed at least once per year to

reduce the amount of sediment and to prevent the reduction of efficiency.


Tankless water heaters also need to be maintained in order to reduce the buildup of

minerals. If regular maintenance is not completed, sediment and mineral deposits can

reduce the efficiency of the water heater and lead to system failure. In Southern California, it

is common for homeowners to see signs of mineral buildup around the fixtures. Glass

shower doors in particular tend to become cloudy due to the combination of mineral

deposits and water. The same minerals can accumulate inside the water heater and affect

its efficiency.



Tank water heaters take up space, but tankless

systems can be mounted on a wall


Traditional water heaters need to be placed somewhere that can hold the weight of the unit.

Storage water heaters are often installed in a closet, garage, or utility room. Tankless water

heaters are typically mounted on a wall, which means there is less space needed in a home.

Some homeowners prefer this option because it frees up square footage, but it is also

important to consider the requirements of the new system.


The location of a tankless water heater is incredibly important because the system will need

to be vented, connected to gas, and have access to electricity, water, and condensate

removal. If the tankless water heater is placed in the wrong location, it could be very difficult

to complete the installation or complete repairs in the future.


Here are a few reasons why a traditional water

heater may be the best option


A traditional water heater may be right for your home if:

  • Your existing traditional water heater has been working well.

  • You are happy with the amount of hot water it provides.

  • You want to reduce your expenses.

  • You want to avoid a major installation.

  • You do not want a tankless system.


For many homeowners, a tank water heater is the best option.


Here are a few reasons why a tankless system

may be the best option


A tankless water heater may be right for your home if:

  • You want a steadier supply of hot water.

  • Space is an issue.

  • You want to reduce your utility bills.

  • You can afford the higher up-front costs.

  • You are open to making some major changes to your home.


Many people who are considering a move to a tankless water heater are concerned with the

installation costs and requirements. Tankless water heaters typically require more major

modifications to the home, which often increases the total cost of the installation.


Here’s what Kramer’s Plumbing looks at when a

homeowner is trying to decide between

traditional and tankless water heaters


While a few factors will always be more important than others, there are a number of

considerations that must be made when choosing between a traditional and tankless water

heater.


These considerations include the needs of the home in terms of hot water, how many

bathrooms are in the home, the location of the water heater, gas and venting, plumbing,

drainage, condensate, and age, your budget, maintenance requirements, and whether you

are replacing or converting.


By taking the time to research the options and understand the differences, it can be much

easier to make an educated decision that benefits everyone.



FAQs: Tankless vs. Tank Water Heaters


Is tankless better than a tank water heater?


Tankless water heaters can be more efficient and offer a steadier supply of hot water, but

they often come with a higher price tag.


Is a tank water heater still a good choice?


Yes. A traditional water heater can be an excellent choice for many homeowners.


Does tankless mean unlimited hot water?


Tankless water heaters can provide a steadier supply of hot water, provided the system is

sized correctly for the needs of the home.


Is tankless more expensive to install?


Yes, tankless water heaters usually require more modifications to the home in order to be

installed.


Which water heater is better for a large family?


It depends on the needs of the home and how much hot water is required at one time. It is

best to consult with a local plumber and explain the needs of your home in detail.


Do tankless water heaters need maintenance?


Yes, tankless water heaters need to be descaled regularly in order to be as efficient as

possible.


Do tank water heaters need maintenance?


Yes, tank water heaters should be flushed on a regular basis in order to reduce the amount

of sediment that accumulates inside the tank.


When should I call Kramer’s Plumbing?


You should call Kramer’s Plumbing any time your water heater is leaking, making strange

noises, not producing enough hot water, or is simply too old. You should also call us when

you are interested in learning more about the differences between a tankless and traditional

water heater.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page